Watch Tower versus BMG music

Watch Tower versus BMG Music Group

In a lawsuit filed with the District Court in the Southern District of New York, Watch Tower Bible & Tract Society of Pennsylvania allege that BMG US, BMG UK, and one or more associated individuals and corporations have infringed their copyright of the song, “Listen, Obey and Be Blessed”, which is available to download for free from the website jw.org.

Watch Tower claim that the song in question features in a sound recording entitled ‘Sing Out Joyfully’ to Jehovah: Song 089, “Listen, Obey and Be Blessed,” and in a motion picture entitled “Become Jehovah’s Friend Song 089. Listen, Obey and Be Blessed,” and in a book “Sing to Jehovah”, all of which were copyrights registered between 2009 and 2019.

They claim the song appears on the album Aled Jones Blessings “in which Album BMG UK claims to be the copyright owner”.

Cover of alleged BMG album in which Watch Tower's song appears.
Cover of alleged BMG album in which Watch Tower’s song appears.

Watch Tower claim that Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Britain, a separate legal entity to the Pennsylvania entity, put Aled Jones on notice that Watch Tower was the owner of all copyrights in the composition of the song, that they had not granted Jones permission to use the song, and objected to his recording and reproduction of it.

Jone’s sent a copy of this letter from Watch Tower to BMG UK and they responded to Watch Tower indicating that they obtained a license to record, reproduce and publicly perform the song from a German collective rights society called GEMA. Instead of BMG providing evidence of this license they requested Watch Tower contact GEMA directly. However GEMA claim they denied BMG’s request because the latter did not have the right to license the work.

Furthermore, Watch Tower claims that neither BMG UK anor BMG US followed the statutory procedures necessary to obtain a compulsory mechanical license to use the song. BMG UK did inform Watch Tower that BMG US were in the process of obtaining such a license but it is alleged that the latter hadn’t done so in a timely manner.

In respect of the alleged infringements, Watch Tower are seeking
(a) an injunction against BMG, Aled Jones and all others connected to the infringed material to prevent the song from any further reproduction, copying, distribution, performance or exploitation.
(b) actual damages from the act of infringing their copyright, all profits realized as a result of the infringement, in amounts determined at trial or, if Watch Tower prefers, statutory damages pursuant to copyright law, each with prejudgment and post-judgment interest thereon.
(c) costs and attorneys’ fees incurred as a result of BMG’s alleged unlawful acts.

Additional Resources

4 thoughts on “Watch Tower versus BMG music

  1. I’m my own personal opinion there is bigger problems in the world ,I don’t know if any one reading this has lived in a 3rd world country where the black people goes thro the white man’s rubbish just so his family can eat and he’s one of the lucky ones ,so carrying on about this in the grand scale of things more so now with this virus in my eyes is minimal and materialistic to sue over someone quoting something from a verse ,surely all the people singing the verses in public should pay royalties if your heading down that route ,and if anything j.w should be privileged people are saying the same verse after all the j.w sect spends millions of pounds getting people so say they same thing as them ,do they not ?

    1. Totally agree. Jesus spoke of ‘You blind guides! You strain out a gnat but swallow a camel.’ Mt.23:24. JWs seem to have little sense of priorities. When Jesus was told that there another proclaiming the Christian message, John and James said ‘do you want us to to stop him?’ Do not you men try and prevent him, for he that is not against you is for you.’ Lu.9:49,50. What a balanced attitude Christ had. If JW.org was more like this they might get along further.

  2. This is brilliant. Watch Tower is placed in the embarrassing position of taking no action, which makes them appear hypocritical to people who know what they preach about interfaith, or taking action, which forces them to go public with their beliefs about interfaith, which they generally obscure for public consumption.

    It’s interesting that they say that Jehovah’s Witnesses would see it as hypocritical to allow the song to be used. It’s true that some JWs have commented negatively but others have said they really liked Aled’s version, seeing it in a positive light. Clearly, rank and file JWs are confused as to what they should think until Watch Tower tells them what to think.

  3. That’s a fine witness given to Aled Jones and those who like him. Well done Watchtower. Shot yourselves in the foot again.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.